I recently received a question from a reader about whether the nutrition and health benefits of spirulina were worth the cost. You’ve probably noticed that a pound of spirulina typically sells online for about $50. Is it worth shelling out the big bucks on spirulina?
Unfortunately, spirulina is one of the massively over-hyped superfoods. The nutrition content is often misleading.
Just check out these nutrition facts listed by a seller of spirulina powder:
- “Spirulina has 2300% more iron than spinach.
- Spirulina has 3900% more beta carotene than carrots.
- Spirulina has 300% more calcium than whole milk.
- Spirulina has 375% more protein than tofu.”
These statements make spirulina look like an ultra-concentrated superfood. And these statements may be true – technically.
But these nutrition facts are “per calorie” and not “per serving”, and there’s a huge difference between the two.
Spirulina Hype vs. Spirulina Reality
A “beginner dose” of spirulina powder is up to 1 teaspoon (3-5 grams, approximately 10 calories) per day while a “normal dose” is 1-2 teaspoons per day (6-10 grams). A “therapeutic dose” is generally considered to be a tablespoon (about 16 grams, approx. 20 calories).
A 16 gram serving of spirulina does not contain 2300% more iron than a serving of spinach, nor does it contain 375% more protein per serving than tofu.
While spirulina typically contains about 60% protein, on average, you’d be be lucky to get maybe 2 grams of protein in a teaspoon and perhaps 6 in a tablespoon at most.
As a protein source, spirulina is extremely expensive. There are much cheaper, whole food sources of protein that also provide adequate calories to be part of a meal, not just a dietary supplement.
Vitamin B12 Content of Spirulina
One way that the nutritional benefits of spirulina are dangerously over-hyped is in its B12 content. Surprisingly, most online marketers of spirulina still promote it as a rich source of vitamin B12 despite studies showing that the B12 found in spirulina (and all other plant sources) are an analogue form that is not metabolized by humans.
Not only will the analogue form of vitamin B12 found in spirulina NOT prevent vitamin B12 deficiency, it might actually facilitate deficiency since analogue B12 competes with bio-available B12 for absorption.
In short, spirulina is not a B12 supplement and should never be relied on to provide this vitamin.
Other Nutrients in Spirulina
Spirulina is a good source of vitamin B2, copper, and it contains some iron (up to 2mg per tablespoon). However, it is not a particularly rich source of any other essential vitamin or mineral, including calcium (less than 9mg in a tablespoon).
When you look at the nutrition information of spirulina per serving, it doesn’t really stand out from other whole foods, and many whole foods simply have higher amounts of nutrients per serving than spirulina.
Nutrition labels on a variety of spirulina products may vary, and they tend to have “more nutrition” than what is listed in official food nutrient databases, such as the USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference from which I get most of my nutrition facts from.
This alone makes me skeptical about the integrity of the nutrition value of many spirulina products, not to mention the erroneous claims about B12 content that manufactures and sellers often promote.
Dried and powdered spirulina, as it is currently marketed and sold, is not a whole food. While Aztecs may have consumed it as part of their diet prior to the 16th century, and it is still consumed in Central Africa, the dried spirulina cakes typically eaten are not the same thing as highly refined, powdered, pharmaceutical-grade supplements available for sale.
Studied Health Benefits of Spirulina
There have been a variety of animal studies and a handful of human clinical trials that suggest possible health benefits of consuming spirulina including a potential to reduce LDL to HDL cholesterol ratio and improve antioxidant status as well as help with hay fever.
Animal and in vitro studies showing potential benefits of spirulina cannot be claimed as health benefits without analyzing results obtained by conducting double blind, placebo controlled clinical studies on humans.
There is no clinical evidence that spirulina will help with weight loss or detoxification.
The health benefits attributed to spirulina are not unique to this cyanobacteria. In fact, most plant-based whole foods contain compounds (in larger amounts per serving) that promote health, weight loss, and disease prevention.
I am not totally anti-spirulina, though. I mean, I won’t avoid it at a smoothie or juice bar. I do not feel that it is necessary to take it and most people will not experience any health benefit (besides placebo effect) from taking it.
If anything, spirulina is best at being profitable for those who sell it. I just cant justify the expense of this powdered, refined “superfood” when fresh, whole fruits and vegetables provide real food and better nutrition per serving.
And if it’s protein that you want, save your money and buy a quality protein powder. It’s just as processed, but will provide much more protein and cost a lot less.
About Davy & Tracy
We created Incredible Smoothies to help you cultivate health and happiness in your own life. We love to share our favorite green smoothies while also writing about happiness, entrepreneurship, and personal development topics. Read more...